Quality Stage 3 · Risks and requirements · Months 2–4

Approving the risk plan and checking traceability

Quality approves the risk management plan, which fixes the severity and probability scales, the acceptability matrix and the criteria for residual risk before risk analysis begins. As requirements and risk controls are written, quality checks that each risk control traces to a requirement and each requirement traces to a verification protocol. The phase 1 design review closes the stage, with at least one reviewer who did not do the work.

On the map: Approve the risk management plan. Check traceability. Independent phase 1 reviewer.

All 40 tasks

Rows are disciplines, columns are stages 1 to 8. Select a square to open that task.

Back to the full map
Traceability between risk management and design controls: risks are mitigated by requirements, and requirements are verified by procedures with records.
Traceability between risk management and design controls: risks are mitigated by requirements, and requirements are verified by procedures with records. Source: Design Inputs: Best Practices, FAQs, and Examples.

Who you work with

Approve the risk plan before engineering scores hazards, and run the Phase 1 review with a reviewer who did not write the documents. Check the trace from risk to requirement to test.

Decisions you make

Where are the acceptability lines drawn?

The matrix is set before any hazard is scored, so the criteria cannot drift to fit the results. Senior management signs off on acceptability. Many teams add a middle zone that requires every practicable risk control while still allowing release.

What does a traceability check look for?

Requirements with no verification, risk controls with no requirement, and requirements that trace to nothing upstream. A reverse trace from design features back to requirements exposes hidden assumptions.

Who counts as independent at the phase 1 review?

The regulation asks for someone without direct responsibility for the stage under review. In a small company this is a person from the same organization who was not involved in writing the documents, or an outside consultant with comparable expertise.

What has to be true before the review passes?

User needs and requirements are approved, the risk plan is approved, the first risk analysis is done, and open issues have owners. Unresolved concerns are tracked under change control.

Read more

Want to do this kind of work?

See the open positions and apply.

Apply Now
Apply now →